|
|
Post by Bronco73 on Jul 22, 2020 18:05:41 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. Why not.. It sure worked out well for Brent Burns. He was every bit as good a forward as he is a defenseman
|
|
|
|
Post by mrtea on Jul 22, 2020 18:42:24 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. An opposite Brent Burns? Sure, why not? What are your thoughts on AA? Do you see him staying an Oiler as is? I'm just curious, I'm not trying to push for anyone to change positions.
|
|
|
|
Post by mrtea on Jul 22, 2020 18:44:57 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. Why not.. It sure worked out well for Brent Burns. He was every bit as good a forward as he is a defenseman Which player are you talking about or both? Again I'm only curious and not sold on the idea other than it would be a neat twist.
|
|
|
|
Post by Marshall Bruce Mathers III on Jul 22, 2020 18:53:14 GMT -7
An opposite Brent Burns? Sure, why not? What are your thoughts on AA? Do you see him staying an Oiler as is? I'm just curious, I'm not trying to push for anyone to change positions. I think AA just needs to find his spot. Whether it's in the top 6, or the 3rd line. I wouldn't mind trying him with Leon and Yamo, if Nuge is on the top line with McDavid. He's versatile, he can play all three forward positions. So, it's just up to Tip to find the right spot for him. A third line of Neal-AA-Chiasson could be appealing. All three could benefit from playing limited third line minutes. I don't see him being D though. Not from what I've seen anyway. My last post I was responding to Broberg possibly being tried on forward.
|
|
|
|
Post by mrtea on Jul 22, 2020 19:16:17 GMT -7
What are your thoughts on AA? Do you see him staying an Oiler as is? I'm just curious, I'm not trying to push for anyone to change positions. I think AA just needs to find his spot. Whether it's in the top 6, or the 3rd line. I wouldn't mind trying him with Leon and Yamo, if Nuge is on the top line with McDavid. He's versatile, he can play all three forward positions. So, it's just up to Tip to find the right spot for him. A third line of Neal-AA-Chiasson could be appealing. All three could benefit from playing limited third line minutes. I don't see him being D though. Not from what I've seen anyway. My last post I was responding to Broberg possibly being tried on forward. I knew that, that's why I inquired about AA. Personally I haven't seen enough of him to make good judgement. He certainly has good speed, speaking of good speed I was impressed with Ennis's speed and especially work ethic. He's a digger! I think Nuge will do pretty good on McDavid's wing and he's another guy to take face offs if McDavid gets waved out.
|
|
|
|
Post by Bronco73 on Jul 22, 2020 21:06:40 GMT -7
What are your thoughts on AA? Do you see him staying an Oiler as is? I'm just curious, I'm not trying to push for anyone to change positions. I think AA just needs to find his spot. Whether it's in the top 6, or the 3rd line. I wouldn't mind trying him with Leon and Yamo, if Nuge is on the top line with McDavid. He's versatile, he can play all three forward positions. So, it's just up to Tip to find the right spot for him. A third line of Neal-AA-Chiasson could be appealing. All three could benefit from playing limited third line minutes. I don't see him being D though. Not from what I've seen anyway. My last post I was responding to Broberg possibly being tried on forward. Sorry I was referring to Broberg
|
|
|
|
Post by fogolin2 on Jul 23, 2020 6:31:18 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. An opposite Brent Burns? Sure, why not? A Bufflin Dustin!
|
|
|
|
Post by fogolin2 on Jul 23, 2020 6:35:53 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. I've had this conversation about other players, Darnell Nurse actually, and I think it will get rarer and rarer as time goes on. Players are coached and developed so specifically, from such a young age, that I would think it would be very difficult to transition to another position this far in to ones career. Anything is possible though. Sometimes a kid is just a sauvant and it comes naturally to them. Linus Omark was the best goalie in his league last year. It's 2020. Murder hornets n whatnot....if ever there was a time to try some crazy Mangiapane....
|
|
|
|
Post by Marshall Bruce Mathers III on Jul 23, 2020 6:53:59 GMT -7
I'm just throwing this out there because of a comment Tippett made about Broberg. Tippett said something like "he could play left D, right D, left wing, right wing or center, he looks like a player." Does anyone think it's possible that there could be some merit in trying Broberg as a left wing, more specifically McDavid's left wing? You know, the position that seems no one is able to fill. Could Broberg be so talented that he could make the transition and actually be successful. A few coaches have done this over the years and had success. I'm not saying this is or should be the case with Broberg. It's just that I have a very healthy imagination and once an intriguing idea pops in it is hard to shake. Also now that my mind is going down that path, could AA be turned into a Dman since he doesn't seem to be able to be a good fit on any of the lines? Anyway I'm just throwing it out there, after all this is a discussion forum. I've had this conversation about other players, Darnell Nurse actually, and I think it will get rarer and rarer as time goes on. Players are coached and developed so specifically, from such a young age, that I would think it would be very difficult to transition to another position this far in to ones career. Anything is possible though. Sometimes a kid is just a sauvant and it comes naturally to them. Linus Omark was the best goalie in his league last year. It's 2020. Murder hornets n whatnot....if ever there was a time to try some crazy rieder.... Omark's a goalie? |
|
|
|
Post by drtaf on Jul 23, 2020 10:01:45 GMT -7
That shocked me Too!! Omark had mad skills, did not think glove hand was one of them! AS for PB or AA, I havent seen enough of either but FWIW i think its way easier to go from D to A than A to D, especially at NHL level. Given the hype about Broberg's speed and passing I'd say he could do it in a pinch. AA career-wise has never been known for having anything like defensive acumen so i'd be shocked if that would ever even be considered beyond this forum, (But then again Omark as goalie was my WTF moment of the day)  |
|
|
|
Post by fogolin2 on Jul 23, 2020 15:43:58 GMT -7
I've had this conversation about other players, Darnell Nurse actually, and I think it will get rarer and rarer as time goes on. Players are coached and developed so specifically, from such a young age, that I would think it would be very difficult to transition to another position this far in to ones career. Anything is possible though. Sometimes a kid is just a sauvant and it comes naturally to them. Linus Omark was the best goalie in his league last year. It's 2020. Murder hornets n whatnot....if ever there was a time to try some crazy rieder.... Omark's a goalie? KHL @khl_eng Played full #KHLAllStar bronze medal game as a goalie, made great game-winning save in shootouts – not bad for a forward, @limpanomark Flag of Sweden.
|
|
|
|
Post by Marshall Bruce Mathers III on Jul 23, 2020 16:46:55 GMT -7
KHL @khl_eng Played full #KHLAllStar bronze medal game as a goalie, made great game-winning save in shootouts – not bad for a forward, @limpanomark Flag of Sweden. That's crazy.
|
|
|
|
Post by drtaf on Jul 24, 2020 11:53:40 GMT -7
It speaks to great athletic ability. In soccer, the best goalies are often great forwards and it happens occasionally when a goalie gets sent off or injured and all the subs used, that a forward plays in goal (even at very highest pro level). The common denominator is great reflexes and athletic ability. Caveat to that is in beer league soccer it is the guy whose out of shape and cant run whose picked as goalie:-)
|
|
|
|
Post by SuperDave17 on Sept 11, 2020 11:39:03 GMT -7
Taking a page out of Orr's book?
|
|
|
|
Post by neufab94 on Sept 15, 2020 13:51:06 GMT -7
An opposite Brent Burns? Sure, why not? A Bufflin Dustin! Staios started as a RW, was a decent defensive forward and ended up being a solid d-man. Going the other way, I have been curious for some time how Benning would do as a winger on the 3rd line. I think he has a decent enough shot when inside the circles which we have seen on some of his rushes. His defensive game is okay but clearly the Oilers defense has been suspect at best of which Benning is a part of. This could accomplish a few things, 1) add some defensive responsibility to the forward group, 2) open up Benning's offensive potential which he doesn't do enough as a d-man, 3) make room for an up and coming defensive prospect. I was a heavy Benning critic but I actually missed him when he was out and would like to see if he could up his game as a forward. Not sure I want to see Broberg as a forward because I would love to see some much needed offense coming from the back end. The last few years the Oilers just simply have not got enough offense from their d-corp and with Broberg and Bouchard in the next few years I surely hope that this changes.
|
|
|
|
Post by fogolin2 on Sept 19, 2020 12:49:02 GMT -7
|
|
|
|
Post by yuke on Sept 19, 2020 22:50:35 GMT -7
|
|
|
|
Post by mrtea on Sept 19, 2020 23:01:17 GMT -7
Well it certainly is a break out game, especially since it's the first game of the year. I'm not saying it's not a breakout year, but I'm going to wait till there is a few more of these before I get all giddy. One thing is clear....if he does continue, he has outgrown that league. Something JP has not shown he can do over there.
|
|
|
|
Post by Marshall Bruce Mathers III on Sept 19, 2020 23:15:36 GMT -7
Well it certainly is a break out game, especially since it's the first game of the year. I'm not saying it's not a breakout year, but I'm going to wait till there is a few more of these before I get all giddy. One thing is clear....if he does continue, he has outgrown that league. Something JP has not shown he can do over there. Isn't JP one of the top producers in his league? |
|
|
|
Post by Bronco73 on Sept 19, 2020 23:50:43 GMT -7
Well it certainly is a break out game, especially since it's the first game of the year. I'm not saying it's not a breakout year, but I'm going to wait till there is a few more of these before I get all giddy. One thing is clear....if he does continue, he has outgrown that league. Something JP has not shown he can do over there. Isn't JP one of the top producers in his league? He was fourth overall in scoring last year for Karpat in the SM-liga league 
|
|
